Official Letter No. 8999/CTTPHCM-TTHT, dated July 19, 2023, issued by the Ho Chi Minh City Tax Department, addresses the issuance of invoices in cases where buyers return goods due to non-conformity or poor quality:
When selling goods or providing services, the seller must issue an invoice to the buyer (including cases where goods or services are used for promotion, advertising, samples; goods or services given as gifts, exchanged, provided as employee compensation, or used for internal consumption — except for goods circulated internally for continued production processes; or goods delivered under lending, borrowing, or return arrangements). The invoice must fully reflect all required details as stipulated, and electronic invoices must follow the standard data format set by the tax authorities.
In cases where an organization or individual has purchased goods, and the seller has issued an invoice and delivered the goods, but the buyer later discovers that the goods do not meet specifications or quality standards and decides to return all or part of the goods, the seller must issue a return invoice to adjust or replace the original invoice. Both the seller and the buyer must agree in writing on the return of the goods.
For goods purchased before January 1, 2023, that were subject to the VAT reduction at 8%, if the goods are returned after December 31, 2022, due to non-conformity or poor quality, the seller must issue a return invoice applying the 8% VAT rate.
Regarding issuing invoices for commercial discounts on goods subject to VAT reduction under Decree No. 15/2022/NĐ-CP:
If the business applies commercial discounts to customers, and the discounted amounts for goods sold in 2022 (at the reduced VAT rate of 8%) are only invoiced after January 1, 2023, then:
- If the discount amount is reflected in the final purchase or the next transaction after December 31, 2022, the discount is adjusted in the taxable price, and the VAT rate follows the current legal regulations at the time the invoice is issued.
- If the discount amount is recorded after the end of the discount program (or period) after December 31, 2022, the seller must issue a new invoice to adjust, applying the 8% VAT rate as used at the time of the original sale.




